Missing Since: 1974-01-10 Location: Chillicothe, Illinois
Pelfrey was last seen in Chillicothe, Ohio on January 10, 1974. She lived on Route 1 and Reservation Circle. She has never been heard from again. For unclear reasons, she was not reported missing until September 1975. Her husband divorced her on the grounds of willful absence around that time. When Pelfrey’s father died in 1999, his obituary mentioned that he had a daughter who was missing. Few details are available in her case, but she is presumed deceased. Investigating Agency Ross County Sheriff Department 740-773-1185 Source Information Ohio Attorney General’s Office NamUs The Chillicothe Gazette Updated 1 time since October 12, 2004. Last updated March 19, 2022; casefile added.