Missing Since: 1974-06-04 Location: Silverthorne, Colorado
Reynolds was last seen in Silverthorne, Colorado on June 4, 1974. She was on the Blue River in a rowboat with three other people, including her husband, when the boat capsized. Reynolds’s companions were able to make it to shore safely, but she disappeared. Searchers found her jacket half a mile downstream, but they found no other sign of her. She is presumed drowned, but her body has never been found. Investigating Agency Summit County Sheriff’s Office 970-423-8913 Source Information NamUs Whereabouts Still Unknown Colorado Bureau of Investigation The Fort Collins Coloradoan Updated 1 time since October 12, 2004. Last updated July 11, 2017; casefile added.